Altered Carbon

misubisu

8/10

12/18/2025

## **Altered Carbon (2018) Review: A Flawed Masterpiece - 8/10** *Altered Carbon* is a series defined by one of the most stunning dichotomies in modern television: a first season of near-perfect, visionary science fiction, and a second season that squanders almost everything that made it great. The combined experience is a frustrating but ultimately rewarding journey, held aloft by the sheer, untouchable brilliance of its initial chapter. ### Season 1: A Solid 10/10 - A Mind Explosion The first season is a landmark achievement. It is a dense, neo-noir cyberpunk epic that plunges you into a world where consciousness is digitized, stored in "stacks," and transferred between bodies ("sleeves"). The concepts were revolutionary: the existential horror of sleeving a child's consciousness into an elderly body due to bureaucratic priority, the eternal privilege of the Meths (the immortal rich) who back themselves up to orbiting satellites, and the grim penal system of storing criminal minds in virtual hellscapes. This was not just high-concept window dressing. **The show was a mind explosion like nothing I had ever watched before** because every idea was grounded in profound character work. Through Takeshi Kovacs' investigation, we explored the complex psyches of characters grappling with lost identities, borrowed trauma, and the fundamental question of what makes a "self" when the body is just clothing. The inner monologues, the visual storytelling, and the **perfect casting**—particularly Joel Kinnaman's world-weary physicality and James Purefoy's decadent menace—created a gritty, philosophically rich, and utterly captivating world. It was a 10/10: ambitious, smart, stylish, and emotionally resonant. ### Season 2: A Disappointing 5/10 - The Great Diminishing The anticipation for Season 2 was immense, which made the letdown so severe. Re-casting Kovacs with Anthony Mackie, while logical in-universe, lost the specific, hard-boiled chemistry of the first season. The dense, multi-layered detective plot was replaced by a simpler, more conventional quest narrative. The profound philosophical questions were traded for shallower action beats, and the stunning, rain-soaked neo-noir aesthetic gave way to a more generic sci-fi look. The complex web of character motivations unraveled into something far less compelling. It was a dramatic reduction in scope, intelligence, and visceral impact. ### The Final Verdict **8/10 - A Testament to Unmatched Heights** The overall score is an average that doesn't tell the full story. It is a rating fiercely defended by the towering achievement of Season 1, a season so meticulously crafted, so intellectually stimulating, and so visually audacious that it compensates for the profound misfire that followed. *Altered Carbon* is essential viewing for its first season alone—a groundbreaking piece of sci-fi storytelling. Just consider the journey complete when the credits roll on Season 1's finale, and view Season 2 as a largely separate, underwhelming footnote to a true masterpiece.